Supreme Court of Florida June 26, 2014, SC12-2101 (Paul Christopher Hildwin v. State of Florida)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-06-2014

combined-opinion

Supreme Court of Florida

____________

No. SC12-2101

____________

PAUL CHRISTOPHER HILDWIN,

Appellant,

vs.

STATE OF FLORIDA,

Appellee.

[June 26, 2014]

PER CURIAM.

Paul Christopher Hildwin appeals from the denial of postconviction relief in

this death penalty case. We reverse and conclude that newly discovered evidence

that identifies the donor of DNA left at the crime scene compels that a new trial be

granted.1 The newly discovered DNA evidence now establishes that the victim’s

boyfriend, William Haverty, and not the defendant, Hildwin, was the provider of

1. We have jurisdiction of Hildwin’s appeal under article V, section 3(b)(1),

of the Florida Constitution because the lower court’s order concerns the denial of

postconviction relief from a capital conviction for which a sentence of death was

imposed.

biological material found on two items at the crime scene: a pair of women’s

underwear and a white washcloth. Importantly, this new scientific evidence

completely changes the nature of the evidence relied upon by the State at trial,

since at trial, the State introduced the underwear and washcloth to show that the

biological material left on the items was consistent with the defendant, Hildwin,

and was inconsistent with Haverty. Hildwin’s defense, however, maintained that

Haverty killed the victim.

In other words, this new scientific evidence completely discredits the

scientific evidence that the State relied upon at trial when the State argued that

Hildwin’s defense was not supported by the evidence. In fact, exactly the opposite

has now been shown to be true—the biological material matches the very person

that Hildwin argued at trial was responsible for the murder.

Specifically, at trial, the State prosecuted the case based on a false theory of

scientific evidence that was woven throughout its presentation of evidence and

argument—scientific evidence that has now been totally discredited.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.