Ohio Court of Appeals May 1, 2014, 13 MA 149 (State v. Koczwara)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-05-2014

[Cite as State v. Koczwara, 2014-Ohio-1946.]

STATE OF OHIO, MAHONING COUNTY

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS

SEVENTH DISTRICT

STATE OF OHIO, )

) CASE NO. 13 MA 149

PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, )

)

VS. ) OPINION

)

JEFFREY KOCZWARA, )

)

DEFENDANT-APPELLANT. )

CHARACTER OF PROCEEDINGS: Criminal Appeal from County Court No.

2, Case No. 13TRC433.

JUDGMENT: Affirmed.

APPEARANCES:

For Plaintiff-Appellee: Attorney Paul Gains

Prosecuting Attorney

Attorney Ralph Rivera

Assistant Prosecuting Attorney

21 West Boardman Street, 6th Floor

Youngstown, Ohio 44503

For Defendant-Appellant: Attorney Edward Czopur

42 North Phelps Street

Youngstown, Ohio 44503

JUDGES:

Hon. Joseph J. Vukovich

Hon. Cheryl L. Waite

Hon. Mary DeGenaro

Dated: May 1, 2014

[Cite as State v. Koczwara, 2014-Ohio-1946.]

VUKOVICH, J.

{¶1} Defendant-appellant Jeffrey Koczwara appeals the decision of County

Court No. 2 which denied his motion to suppress. Appellant contends that the officer

lacked reasonable suspicion to conduct field sobriety tests. His argument proceeds

under the theory that the court can only view that evidence existing prior to the time

he was asked to step out of the vehicle. However, it is well-established that an officer

can ask any lawfully stopped driver to alight from the vehicle during the traffic stop

without having any justification for doing so, and it is also well-established that an

officer’s subjective motivations do not invalidate a constitutionally permissible stop

and its components.

{¶2} As an officer is permitted to order a driver out, the fact that the officer

asked the driver out with a desire to conduct field sobriety tests (at a point when he

allegedly did not yet have reasonable suspicion of OVI) does not invalidate the order

to alight from the vehicle. Thus, appellant’s imbalance and instability as he alighted

from the vehicle can be considered in the evaluation of whether there existed

reasonable suspicion to conduct field sobriety tests.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.