Utah Supreme Court August 29, 2014, 20120831 (Southam v. South Despain Ditch Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-08-2014

This opinion is subject to revision before final

publication in the Pacific Reporter.

2014 UT 35

IN THE

SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF UTAH

———————

PAUL SOUTHAM,

Plaintiff and Appellant,

v.

SOUTH DESPAIN DITCH COMPANY, a Utah

nonprofit mutual irrigation company,

Defendant and Appellee.

———————

No. 20120831

Filed August 29, 2014

———————

Third District, Salt Lake

The Honorable L.A. Dever

No. 080923857

———————

Attorneys:

Phillip E. Lowry, Salt Lake City, for plaintiff

Dale B. Kimsey, Sandy, Dean Smith, Midvale, for defendant

———————

JUSTICE LEE authored the opinion of the Court, in which

CHIEF JUSTICE DURRANT, ASSOCIATE CHIEF JUSTICE NEHRING,

JUSTICE DURHAM, and JUSTICE PARRISH joined.

———————

JUSTICE LEE, opinion of the Court:

¶1 This lawsuit was filed by a predecessor of Paul Southam

against South Despain Ditch Company. Southam acquired shares

in South Despain in contravention of corporate restrictions on

transferability of South Despain shares. When the company

sought to enforce those restrictions against Southam, he chal-

lenged their enforceability and asserted that their enforcement put

South Despain in breach of its obligations in contract, fiduciary

duty, and the Utah Nonprofit Corporation Act.

¶2 The district court granted summary judgment for South

Despain. We affirm. Because the restrictions on the transfer of

South Despain shares are enforceable, Southam acquired no rights

SOUTHAM V. SOUTH DESPAIN DITCH COMPANY

Opinion of the Court

as a shareholder. And for that reason his claims for breach of con-

tract, breach of fiduciary duty, and violation of the Utah Revised

Nonprofit Corporation Act also fail as a matter of law.

I

¶3 South Despain is a nonprofit mutual irrigation company

that manages and maintains the distribution of surplus runoff wa-

ter from Little Cottonwood Creek. It distributes that surplus water

to its shareholders in Sandy, Utah.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.