Court of Appeals of North Carolina May 6, 2014, COA13-720 (City of Asheville v. Aly)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-05-2014

NO. COA13-720

NORTH CAROLINA COURT OF APPEALS

Filed: 6 May 2014

CITY OF ASHEVILLE,

Petitioner

v. Buncombe County

No. 10 CVS 5296

ROGER S. ALY,

Respondent

Appeal by petitioner from order entered 4 January 2013 by

Judge James U. Downs in Buncombe County Superior Court. Heard

in the Court of Appeals 20 November 2013.

Ward and Smith, P.A., by Rendi L. Mann-Stadt, and Office of

the City Attorney, by Kelly Whitlock, for petitioner-

appellant.

Adams, Hendon, Carson, Crow and Saenger, P.A., by Robert C.

Carpenter and John C. Hunter, for respondent-appellee.

DAVIS, Judge.

Petitioner City of Asheville (“the City”) appeals from the

trial court’s order finding that the termination of Respondent

Roger S. Aly (“Respondent”) from his employment with the City of

Asheville Police Department (“APD”) was not justified. After

careful review, we affirm the trial court’s order.

Factual Background

-2-

In July 2009, while employed by the APD as a police

officer, Respondent rented a laptop computer for his personal

use from a rental store called Aaron’s. The rental agreement

stated the computer was “rent to own,” meaning that after a

certain number of payments, Respondent would have the option of

purchasing the computer. During the rental period, Respondent

used the computer to access his personal email, download

photographs, and back up his Blackberry cell phone.

In December 2009, Respondent returned the computer to

Aaron’s. He testified that before doing so, he attempted to

remove the files that he had downloaded onto the computer by

highlighting the files, moving them into the “recycling bin,”

and selecting “empty.” He further testified that, unbeknownst

to him, this procedure failed to remove the files that

Respondent had imported from his cell phone and downloaded onto

the computer. These files contained, in part, various pictures

of Respondent’s family, friends, pets, and fellow APD officers

in uniform.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.