Supreme Court of Arkansas September 11, 2014, CR-13-927 (State v. Rainer.dissent)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-09-2014

Cite as 2014 Ark. 373

SUPREME COURT OF ARKANSAS

No. CR-13-927

STATE OF ARKANSAS Opinion Delivered September 11, 2014

APPELLANT

APPEAL FROM THE MISSISSIPPI

V. COUNTY CIRCUIT COURT

CHICKASAWBA DISTRICT

SHAWN TREVELL RAINER [NO. 47CR-2009-193]

APPELLEE

HONORABLE JOHN N.

FOGLEMAN, JUDGE

DISSENTING OPINION ON DENIAL

OF REHEARING.

JOSEPHINE LINKER HART, Associate Justice

I stand by my identification of the mistakes of law and fact that I noted in my dissent.

The gross deviation from the previously settled standard of review, the abandonment of the

most basic rules of argument preservation—that the argument be raised and ruled on by the

trial court, and the application of an apparently new doctrine that this court may deny Rule

37 relief for any reason, are egregious enough to warrant a rehearing of this case. I,

however, wish to note an additional reason why not rehearing this case is a grave mistake.

In federal habeas corpus proceedings, our procedural default jurisprudence is granted

deference. We will likely lose that deference if federal habeas defendants successfully argue

that we do not apply our rules consistently. The majority in the case before us has clearly

deviated from the hitherto settled way in which we have procedurally limited and barred

arguments raised on appeal.

Cite as 2014 Ark. 373

First, Rainer notes in his rehearing petition, it was our settled practice to require that

specific arguments are made to the circuit court before we consider the same on appeal. He

cites as an example Walker v. State, 301 Ark. 218, 783 S.W. 2d 44 (1990), where this court

refused to consider an argument based on Arkansas Rule of Evidence 403 when the appellant

had only argued relevance to the trial court. Here, the State only argued relevance, yet the

majority—on its own initiative—stated that a relevancy argument automatically preserved

an argument based on Arkansas Rule of Evidence 405, which concerns methods of proving

character.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.