Supreme Court of Pennsylvania December 15, 2014, 12 WAP 2013 (Alderwoods (PA), Inc. v. Duquesne Light, Aplt.)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-12-2014

[J-78-2013]

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA

WESTERN DISTRICT

ALDERWOODS (PENNSYLVANIA), INC., : No. 12 WAP 2013

A WHOLLY OWNED SUBSIDIARY OF :

SERVICE CORPORATION : Appeal from the Order of the Superior

INTERNATIONAL, T/A BURTON L. : Court entered July 27, 2012 at No. 1967

HIRSCH FUNERAL HOME, : WDA 2010, reversing the Order of the

: Court of Common Pleas of Allegheny

Appellee : County entered December 13, 2010 at No.

: GD-09-14720 and remanding.

:

v. : ARGUED: October 15, 2013

:

:

DUQUESNE LIGHT COMPANY, :

:

Appellant :

DISSENTING OPINION

MADAME JUSTICE TODD DECIDED: DECEMBER 15, 2014

While the majority has presented a thoughtful and reasonable legal analysis, I

must respectfully dissent because the majority’s affirmance of the Superior Court’s

decision is based on an issue outside of the scope of our grant of review.

The majority finds that Appellant — Duquesne Light — has a duty to take

reasonable measures to avoid harm to one of its customers prior to restoring power,

when it has actual or constructive knowledge of a danger created by an overvoltage

triggered by downed power lines, and that this duty could entail warning the customer of

the dangerous situation prior to restoring power to the customer’s premises. I

acknowledge that the Superior Court found Duquesne Light to have such a duty to warn

under the particular circumstances of this case — in addition to a duty to inspect the

premises of Appellee (“Hirsch Funeral Home”) — prior to reconnecting power.

However, I deem it inappropriate to opine on the duty to warn at present, as we

have not had the benefit of briefing from the parties with respect thereto — a situation

which, in my view, is the probable result of the manner in which our Court structured the

order granting allowance of appeal. Our Court granted allowance of appeal to address

three specific questions, as stated by Duquesne Light:

1.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.