Michigan Court of Appeals December 18, 2014, 316068 (Lale Roberts v. Kathryn Salmi Lpc)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-12-2014

STATE OF MICHIGAN

COURT OF APPEALS

LALE ROBERTS and JOAN ROBERTS, FOR PUBLICATION

December 18, 2014

Plaintiffs-Appellants,

v No. 316068

Houghton Circuit Court

KATHRYN SALMI, LPC, d/b/a SALMI LC No. 2012-015075-NH

CHRISTIAN COUNSELING,

Defendant-Appellee.

Before: MURPHY, C.J., and SAWYER and M. J. KELLY, JJ.

SAWYER, J. (dissenting).

I respectfully dissent.

While the majority lays out a strong policy argument in favor of the conclusion that we

should create a duty between a therapist and a patient’s parents under the circumstances of this

case, I nonetheless believe that represents a policy decision best left to the Legislature. In

reaching this conclusion, I am guided by the wisdom expressed by the Supreme Court in Henry v

The Dow Chemical Co.1 While the majority correctly points out that the facts, as well as the

specific question presented, is significantly different than those presented in our case, the more

fundamental jurisprudential question is the same: when should a court exercise its authority to

modify the common law and recognize a duty in tort law and when is that determination best left

to the Legislature?

In Henry,2 the Court noted the extensive fact-finding and resolution of conflicting policy

concerns that would be required:

Although we recognize that the common law is an instrument that may

change as times and circumstances require, we decline plaintiffs’ invitation to

alter the common law of negligence liability to encompass a cause of action for

medical monitoring. Recognition of a medical monitoring claim would involve

1

473 Mich 63; 701 NW2d 684 (2005).

2

Id. at 68-69.

-1-

extensive fact-finding and the weighing of numerous and conflicting policy

concerns. We lack sufficient information to assess intelligently and fully the

potential consequences of recognizing a medical monitoring claim.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.