Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas March 19, 2014, PD-1723-12 (Brown, David Earl)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-03-2014

IN THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS NO. PD-1723-12 DAVID EARL BROWN, Appellant v. THE STATE OF TEXAS ON STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW FROM THE FIRST COURT OF APPEALS HARRIS COUNTY Cochran, J., filed a concurring opinion in which Meyers and Alcala, JJ., joined. I join the majority opinion and agree to remand this case for a retrospective competency hearing. I write separately because the resolution of this unusual case is largely dependant upon its specific facts. We do not frequently encounter the situation in which a defendant has shot himself in the head during the trial. Appellant's absence from trial was "voluntary" in the sense that he attempted to commit suicide, but he was also "incompetent" in the sense that he was unable to assist his attorneys throughout the rest of the trial and during the punishment phase. Indeed, there is apparently a question of whether appellant is still incompetent under Article 46B.003. (1) The legal issue is not a pure "Alphonse and Gaston" of which comes first-"voluntary absence" or "incompetency." Rather, the issue is whether, viewing the totality of the facts, there was a "suggestion" of incompetency. If so, the trial judge cannot avoid an informal inquiry and, if warranted, a formal hearing, by finding that the defendant "voluntarily" tried to commit suicide and therefore "voluntarily" absented himself from trial. Certainly a person could voluntarily attempt suicide with full awareness of the consequences and an appreciation of the final nature of that act. But the very act of shooting oneself in the head may well be an irrational act and is certainly some evidence of mental disturbance. (2) And that was precisely the testimony of Dr. Root, appellant's treating psychiatrist.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.