Vermont Superior Court July 28, 2014, 286 (Hart v. Bradford)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-07-2014

Hart v. Bradford, No. 286-12-13 Oecv (Teachout, J., July 28, 2014)

[The text of this Vermont trial court opinion is unofficial. It has been reformatted from the original. The accuracy of the text and the

accompanying data included in the Vermont trial court opinion database is not guaranteed.]

STATE OF VERMONT

SUPERIOR COURT CIVIL DIVISION

Orange Unit Docket # 286-12-13 Oecr

JAMES HART, TRUSTEE of the

JAMES H. HART REALTY TRUST,

Appellant

On appeal from

v. Docket # 21-1-13 Oesc

TOWN OF BRADFORD,

Appellee

SMALL CLAIMS APPEAL

Decision

James Hart, Trustee of the James H. Hart Realty Trust, Plaintiff in the Small Claims case

below, appeals from a judgment of the Small Claims Court dated October 11, 2013. The Small

Claims Court entered judgment below for the Defendant, the Town of Bradford, on Plaintiff’s

claim that the Town damaged Plaintiff’s property when a piece of heavy Town equipment

cleared snow on Plaintiff’s property, and that the Town improperly listed Plaintiff in the Town

Report for nonpayment of taxes.

Mr. Hart represented himself in the Small Claims Court and on appeal. Attorney Charles

Merriman represented the Town in the Small Claims Court and on appeal.

This Court has reviewed the record, listened to the tape recording of the full hearing held

in Small Claims Court on October 11, 2013, reviewed all motions and documents filed in both

the Small Claims Court and this Court, and heard oral argument on April 11, 2014.

Preliminarily, it should be noted as a general matter that it is not the function of the

Superior Court to substitute its own judgment for that of the Small Claims Court Judge. See

Whipple v. Lambert, 145 Vt. 339, 340–41 (1985). Rather, the role of the Superior Court is to

determine whether or not the Judge correctly applied the proper law and procedure, and whether

or not Court rulings are consisted with the record evidence. See id.

With this standard in mind, the Court proceeds to review the four issues raised on appeal.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.