Court of Appeals of Washington February 24, 2014, No. 69316-6-I (Sisley v. Seattle Public Schools)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-02-2014
Grosse, J.
¶1 To overcome a defendant’s motion for summary judgment dismissal in an action for defamation, a plaintiff must establish falsity, unprivileged communication, fault, and damages. Here, the plaintiff failed to do so and thus the summary judgment dismissal of the defamation claim was appropriate. We affirm the trial court’s order.
FACTS
¶2 In March 2009, The Roosevelt News, Roosevelt High School’s student newspaper, published an article entitled, “Sisley Slums Cause Controversy: Developers and neighborhood clash over land use.” The article, written by Emily Shugerman, a student at Roosevelt High School, discussed the controversy regarding development plans on properties surrounding the high school — properties owned by brothers Drake and Hugh Sisley (the Sisley brothers). Shugerman’s article stated:
A fixture on the landscape of Roosevelt, the “Sisley Slums” are the run-down houses located on the block west of 15th and 65th. Also endearingly referred to as the “crack shacks” or “ghetto houses”, these buildings are rental houses owned by the infamous landlords Drake and Hugh Sisley. The Sisleys own more than forty pieces of property in Northeast Seattle, and have a bad reputation amongst both locals and city officials. In fifteen years these brothers have acquired 48 housing and building maintenance code violations, and have also been accused of racist renting policies. In his defense, Drake Sisley says that bad renters are to blame for the accumulating violations. No matter what the reason, the houses have become *86a well-known eye sore - but the neighborhood may not have to deal with them for much longer.[1]
¶3 Following the publication of the article, Drake and Antoinette Sisley (collectively Sisley) filed an action against the Seattle Public Schools (district) for defamation and libel. The district moved for summary judgment pursuant to CR 56.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit