Court of Appeals of Washington August 11, 2014, No. 71362-1-I (Puget Sound Harvesters Ass'n v. Department of Fish & Wildlife)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-08-2014

Lau, J.

¶1 The Puget Sound Harvesters Association (PSHA), an industry group representing nontreaty commercial salmon gill net fishers, appeals the trial court’s dismissal of its petition seeking to invalidate two administrative rules adopted by the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife (WDFW) regulating nontreaty commercial chum salmon fishing in South Puget Sound for the 2012 season. PSHA argues that the 2012 rules violate constitutional principles of equal protection and are arbitrary and capricious. Because there is no constitutional or statutory right to equal catch shares among gear groups and the record supports WDFW’s determination that the 2012 rules satisfy its statutory obligations and management objectives, we affirm.

FACTS

¶2 WDFW is responsible for managing numerous species of salmon across the state. The agency regulates commercial salmon fishing in Puget Sound by gear type and geographic area. This case concerns the chum salmon fishery in areas 10 and 11 in South Puget Sound. The two major gear types used for commercial chum salmon fishing in South Puget Sound are gill nets and purse seines. Purse seiners have larger boats and utilize gear that is capable of catching significantly more fish per hour than gill-netters.

*861¶3 WDFW annually adopts recreational and commercial salmon fishing schedules following a series of meetings with the State, the federal government, tribal fishery managers, industry representatives, and other stakeholders in a public planning process known as “North of Falcon.” Admin. Record (AR) at 3661. The process begins with a preseason salmon run forecast. From this forecast, the treaty tribes and WDFW agree on an allocation of salmon between treaty and nontreaty fishers. Based on this allocation and input from participants in the North of Falcon process, WDFW establishes annual fishing schedules for both tribal-managed and state-managed fisheries.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.