Court of Appeals of Washington September 2, 2014, No. 72322-7-I (Yes for Early Success v. City of Seattle)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-09-2014

Becker, J.

¶1 Yes for Early Success and Seattle voters Laura Chandler and Barbara Flye (collectively Yes for Early Success) appeal the trial court’s August 15, 2014 order directing that the city of Seattle (City) and Kang County use a joint ballot title for two alternative measures concerning early childhood education.

¶2 Although Yes for Early Success designated its initiating document as a notice for discretionary review, it concedes that the challenged order “disposes of every appealable matter in the three consolidated cases, reserving . . . only a statutory appeal of the ballot title for Ordinance 124509.” We conclude that the challenged trial court order is a “Decision Determining Action” and therefore appealable under RAP 2.2(a)(3). See also RAP 5.1(c) (appellate court will treat notice for discretionary review of appealable order as a notice of appeal). Yes for Early Success has acknowledged that it has had a sufficient opportunity to submit briefing addressing the merits of an appeal.

*382¶3 We agree with the trial court that RCW 29A.72.050(3) specifies the mandatory ballot title for the measures under the circumstances present here and controls over any conflicting provisions of the Seattle City Charter. Yes for Early Success’s remaining claims do not establish reversible error. We therefore affirm.

FACTS

¶4 In March 2014, Yes for Early Success filed a petition for City of Seattle Initiative Measure 107 (1-107), “An Act relating to early learning and child care.” Among other things, the initiative would establish a $15 minimum wage for child care teachers and staff, establish a city policy limiting child care costs to no more than 10 percent of income, prohibit violent felons from providing professional child care, and require enhanced training for child care teachers and staff. Sponsors eventually submitted sufficient signatures to present 1-107 to the Seattle City Council (Council) in accordance with the city charter.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.