District Court of Appeal of Florida April 9, 2014, No. 4D11-677 (Young v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-04-2014

DAMOORGIAN, C.J.

Julius Young appeals his judgment and sentence for burglary of a dwelling and third degree grand theft. Young raises multiple issues on appeal.1 We find merit in Young’s argument that the trial court reversibly erred when it permitted the prosecutor to suggest during closing that the photo lineup was credible based on a pretrial ruling. Accordingly, we reverse and remand for a new trial.

On the day the crime was committed, the investigating officer called one of the victims to the police station and presented him with a photo lineup. The victim identified the photo of Young as the man he saw in his home. The photo lineup became the subject of a defense motion to suppress, which the trial court denied. At trial, defense counsel challenged the reliability of the photo lineup, arguing during closing that the lineup was “inherently suggestive, which means it is not competent, credible, reasonable evidence.” On rebuttal, the prosecutor countered that the lineup comported with standard police procedures and went on to state:

The officer he didn’t — he didn’t suggest anything, nothing was unduly suggestive. Uh, if — if it was unduly suggestive, you wouldn’t have heard that because that would have been a matter of law for the Judge to decide. And remember we talked about that in jury selection, everyone has a role? Judge’s role is a matter of law. So if there were anything to suppress because it was unduly suggestive, it would have been suppressed, but it wasn’t.

Defense counsel objected and moved for a mistrial, claiming that the state’s argument was inappropriate because defense counsel never said that the lineup was illegal. The court denied the motion for mistrial but provided the following curative instruction:

All right, once — once again, ladies and gentlemen, you’ve heard it several times even from the attorneys and you’ll hear it from me again at this moment, decisions of law, rulings on the law are the province of the Court.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.