District Court of Appeal of Florida June 27, 2014, No. 2D13-5078 (Collier County v. Hussey)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-06-2014

CASANUEVA, Judge.

Collier County seeks review of an order denying approval of a joint settlement agreement (Settlement Agreement). Approval of the Settlement Agreement was sought pursuant to the Bert J. Harris, Jr., Private Property Rights Protection Act, section 70.001, Florida Statutes (2008)1 *37(the Bert Harris Act), and the Settlement Agreement attempted to resolve alleged Bert Harris Act and regulatory taking claims. The trial court denied approval of the Settlement Agreement, finding it would contravene the application of laws and regulations without protecting the public interests served by such laws and regulations, including the Growth Policy Act2 and the Federal Endangered Species Act.3 We conclude the Bert Harris Act presuit settlement procedures were not available to the parties at the time they entered into the Settlement Agreement and thus affirm the trial court’s order denying approval as right for the wrong reasons. We write to address only the issue of timing and decline to address the remaining legal conclusions reached by the trial court.

Background

This matter arises from two consolidated actions in which property owners Francis D. Hussey, Jr., Mary P. Hussey, Winchester Lakes Corporation, Sean Hussey, Jr., Successor Trustee to Jose Lombillo, Trustee, and Eduardo Pereiro, Trustee (collectively “the Property Owners”) sued Collier County (“the County”), the Governor of Florida (in his official capacity), and the Florida Department of Community Affairs (now the Florida Department of Economic Opportunity), seeking damages in excess of $91,000,000 for alleged Bert Harris Act and regulatory taking claims. The Property Owners’ claims stem primarily from a 2002 amendment to Collier County’s Growth Management Plan referred to as the “Rural Fringe Amendment.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.