Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania January 9, 2014 (Miller v. Unemployment Compensation Board of Review)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-01-2014

*486OPINION BY

Senior Judge FRIEDMAN.

Sean Miller (Claimant) petitions for review of the May 7, 2013, order of the Unemployment Compensation Board of Review (UCBR) affirming the decision of a referee to deny Claimant unemployment compensation (UC) benefits. The UCBR determined that Claimant was ineligible for benefits because he was discharged from work for willful misconduct under section 402(e) of the Unemployment Compensation Law (Law).1 We reverse.

Claimant worked for PepBoys (Employer) as a full-time electrician from July 21, 2009, through December 18, 2012. On December 12, 2012, Claimant needed to install a radio in a customer’s vehicle and drove the vehicle to the first available bay. (UCBR’s Findings of Fact, Nos. 1-3.)

An employee named Paul, who was not working at the time, told Claimant, “This is my bay. You need to go somewhere else.” Claimant explained to Paul that he needed to install a radio in a customer’s car and would be done with the installation in 30 minutes. Paul told Claimant, “That’s too bad,” and slammed down the bay door and locked it. (Id., Nos. 4-6.)

Claimant attempted to unlock the bay door. Paul pushed Claimant’s hands off the chain and locked the door again. Claimant and Paul argued about the use of the bay. Claimant told Paul, “We don’t need to fight right now. I have a customer waiting.” Paul told Claimant, ‘You want to live?” and grabbed Claimant by the shirt. Paul shoved Claimant backwards a few steps, and Claimant shoved Paul backwards a few steps. (Id., Nos. 7-11.)

The argument ended, and the service manager approached Claimant and Paul about the incident. The service manager, general manager, and human resources personnel subsequently watched surveillance video of the incident. The surveillance video verified that Paul started the altercation by pushing Claimant, who knocked over a tool cart, and Claimant then pushed Paul back in retaliation. Claimant was in an open area where he could have retreated. (Id., Nos. 12-18.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.