Court of Appeals of Utah November 14, 2014, 20120789-CA (In re Anna Aagard Trust)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-11-2014

2014 UT App 269

_________________________________________________________

THE UTAH COURT OF APPEALS

IN THE MATTER OF THE ANNA BLACKHAM AAGARD TRUST, ET AL.

W. KIM AAGARD,

Petitioner and Appellant,

v.

DIANE A. JORGENSEN,

Respondent and Appellee.

Opinion

No. 20120789-CA

Filed November 14, 2014

Sixth District Court, Manti Department

The Honorable Marvin D. Bagley

No. 113600013

Thomas A. Mecham, Alexander Dushku, and

Christopher S. Hill, Attorneys for Appellant

Clark R. Nielsen and Kathryn J. Steffey, Attorneys

for Appellee

JUDGE J. FREDERIC VOROS JR. authored this Opinion, in which

JUDGE MICHELE M. CHRISTIANSEN and SENIOR JUDGE PAMELA T.

GREENWOOD concurred.1

VOROS, Judge:

¶1 This case involves a dispute among family members over

control of ranch land in Northern Utah. Diane A. Jorgensen

1. The Honorable Pamela T. Greenwood, Senior Judge, sat by

special assignment as authorized by law. See generally Utah R.

Jud. Admin. 11-201(6).

In the matter of the Anna Blackham Aagard Trust

raises sheep on the land. Her brother, W. Kim Aagard, is the sole

manager of the Aagard family company and the sole trustee of

more than a dozen Aagard family trusts. Kim sought court

approval of a modification to the Company’s operating

agreement that would strip Diane of her power to veto any sale

of land. The district court ruled that the modification would

create a conflict of interest. Kim appeals. We reverse.

BACKGROUND

The Ranch, the Trusts, and the Company

¶2 The Aagard ranch covers nearly nine thousand acres of

land spanning the border of northeast Utah and southwest

Wyoming. To manage and transfer ownership of the ranch land,

Welby and Opal Aagard created an LLC (Company) and a set

of family trusts. Welby and Opal created trusts for themselves

and for many family members, including their children (Kim

and Diane), their children’s spouses, and each of their

grandchildren.2 Welby and Opal originally served as co-trustees

of the two trusts created for their own benefit.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.