Court of Appeals of Utah September 18, 2014, 20130574-CA (Christensen v. Rolfe)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-09-2014

2014 UT App 223

_________________________________________________________

THE UTAH COURT OF APPEALS

AMANDA CHRISTENSEN AND STACY DERU,

Plaintiffs and Appellees,

v.

NANNETTE ROLFE,

Defendant and Appellant.

Opinion

No. 20130574-CA

Filed September 18, 2014

Third District Court, Salt Lake Department

The Honorable Anthony B. Quinn and

The Honorable Vernice S. Trease

Nos. 120901407, 120904081

Sean D. Reyes and Brent A. Burnett, Attorneys

for Appellant

Jason Schatz, Attorney for Appellees

JUDGE J. FREDERIC VOROS JR. authored this Opinion, in which

JUDGES JAMES Z. DAVIS and STEPHEN L. ROTH concurred.

VOROS, Judge:

¶1 The Utah Driver License Division (the Division) suspended

the driver licenses of Appellees Amanda Christensen and Stacy

Deru (Licensees). The district court set aside the suspensions.

Through Nannette Rolfe,1 the Division now contends that the

district court erred by reviewing these informal administrative

proceedings on the record rather than conducting trials de novo.

We agree and reverse.

1. Rolfe is the Bureau Chief, Driver Control Bureau, Driver License

Division, Department of Public Safety, State of Utah.

Christensen v. Rolfe

¶2 Licensees were arrested in separate incidents for driving a

motor vehicle under the influence of alcohol in violation of Utah

Code section 41-6a-502. See Utah Code Ann. § 41-6a-502

(LexisNexis 2010). The Division held informal suspension hearings.

See id. § 53-3-223(6) (Supp. 2013). At each hearing, the Licensee’s

attorney was permitted to cross-examine the arresting officer. In

each case, the arresting officer answered some but not all the

attorney’s questions, and the hearing officer did not compel the

officer to answer all the questions. At the conclusion of the

hearings, the Division suspended Licensees’ driver licenses.

¶3 Licensees sought district court review of their license

suspensions. See id. § 53-3-224(1) (2010).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.