Supreme Court of Colorado April 7, 2014, Supreme Court Case No. 13SA306 (Hanlen v. Gessler)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-04-2014

lead-opinion

JUSTICE MARQUEZ

delivered the Opinion of the Court.

11 This case concerns judicial review of Election Rule 10.7.5, which was promulgated by Colorado Secretary of State Seott Gessler ("Secretary") as a temporary or emergency rule on the evening of the November 5, 2013 election. Plaintiffs are registered electors of Adams 12 Five Star School District ("Adams 12") who brought suit against the Secretary and local election officials following the Adams 12 school district director election.

2 Plaintiffs' complaint raised two claims. First, Plaintiffs sought judicial review of the Secretary's authority to promulgate Rule 10.7.5, which permits a designated election official to determine, after ballots have been printed, that an individual appearing on the ballot is "not qualified for office," and directs that votes cast for that individual are "invalid and must not be counted." Second, Plaintiffs sought an order directing the Clerk and Recorder of Adams County, the Clerk and Recorder of the City and County of Broomfield, and the Adams 12 designated election official (collectively, "election officials") to comply with their statutory duties under the election code by completing the vote count and certifying the vote tally for all candidates in the school district director election.

T3 Following a hearing, the district court concluded that Rule 10.7.5 conflicts with seetion 1-5-4128), C.R.S. (2013) (providing that votes shall not be counted for a candidate who dies or withdraws after ballots are printed), and section 22-81-129, C.R.S. (2018) (establishing the vacancy appointment process for school district director offices). Thus, the district court ruled that the Secretary acted in excess of his authority in promulgating the Rule. The district court ordered the defendants to complete and certify the vote count for all candidates in the Adams 12 director district 4 election. The Secretary seeks review of "whether Rule 10.7.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.