New York Court of Appeals March 27, 2014 (People v. Cintron)
Also known as
United States · · · 27-03-2014
*759OPINION OF THE COURT
Chief Judge Lippman.
This is yet another progeny of People v Catu (4 NY3d 242 [2005]). The primary issue on this People’s appeal is whether it constitutes double jeopardy for an appellate court to correct a defendant’s illegal sentence on direct appeal by imposing a term of postrelease supervision (PRS) after the defendant has completed the illegal sentence. We hold that, in the circumstances presented, it does not.
I
In June 2001, a jury found defendant guilty of robbery in the first degree, robbery in the third degree, and petit larceny. Supreme Court sentenced defendant to concurrent terms of imprisonment of 10 years for the first-degree robbery, 3V2 to 7 years for the third-degree robbery, and one year for the petit larceny. The court did not impose the mandatory term of PRS. Defendant appealed his conviction, and the Appellate Division affirmed (People v Cintron, 6 AD3d 338 [1st Dept 2004]).
Defendant then moved to vacate his conviction under CPL 440.10. Supreme Court denied the motion to vacate the conviction. The court nevertheless noted that defendant’s sentence was illegal because it did not include the mandatory term of PRS (see People v Sparber, 10 NY3d 457, 470-471 [2008]) and ordered that defendant be resentenced.
Defendant was conditionally released in May 2008. One month later, Supreme Court resentenced defendant to the original concurrent terms of imprisonment, as well as a five-year term of PRS. In October 2009, the maximum term of his prison sentence passed.
In 2010, we decided People v Williams (14 NY3d 198, 217 [2010]) and held that it constitutes double jeopardy to resentence a defendant and impose PRS after he completes his prison sentence and the direct appeal is over. Shortly thereafter, defendant moved under CPL 440.20 (1) to set aside his second sentence, arguing that the imposition of PRS constituted double jeopardy because he was out of prison on conditional release when it was imposed.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit