Nassau County District Court September 25, 2014 (Putnam Leasing Co. v. Pappas)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-09-2014

OPINION OF THE COURT

Michael A. Ciaffa, J.

*197Decision after Trial

This action involves a claim for monies owed under a 1995 motor vehicle lease between a Greenwich, Connecticut leasing company (plaintiff Putnam Leasing) and an individual who was then residing in Greenwich, Connecticut (defendant Pappas).

The lease, on its face, provided that it “shall be deemed executed at lessor’s place of business” in Greenwich, Connecticut, and it contained a representation by defendant that the vehicle would be “principally operated and garaged in the State of Connecticut.” For reasons not explained, the lease contained a forum selection clause providing for litigation only in courts situated within the State of New York. The lease further specified that it was to be interpreted in accordance with the laws of the State of New York.

Consistent with these provisions, plaintiff commenced an action against defendant in Nassau County District Court in January 1999. It obtained a default judgment against her in March 1999 after she failed to answer the complaint.

Fourteen years later, in March 2013, defendant received notice that a bank account in Boston, Massachusetts was being restrained. Following unsuccessful proceedings in Massachusetts, defendant moved in this court for an order vacating the default judgment.

Defendant’s motion contended that the judgment was void for lack of jurisdiction (CPLR 5015 [a] [4]). Her moving papers further alleged that the parties had “no contacts” with New York that might justify entry of a judgment in this court.

Defendant also challenged the sufficiency of plaintiffs proof of service of process upon her. According to the affidavit of service that was used to obtain the default judgment, plaintiff’s service of process was made “in the manner AGREED UPON BY THE PARTIES,” namely by “certified mail, return receipt requested” addressed to defendant at the Greenwich, Connecticut address set forth in the lease.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.