New York Supreme Court October 27, 2014 (LIDC I, LLC v. Sunrise Mall, LLC)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-10-2014

OPINION OF THE COURT

Daniel R. Palmieri, J.

The plaintiffs’ motion for a stay of termination of their commercial leasehold interests in defendant’s shopping mall pendente lite pursuant to First Natl. Stores v Yellowstone Shopping Ctr. (21 NY2d 630 [1968]), or, in the alternative, for a preliminary injunction pursuant to CPLR 6301, is denied in its entirety.

This matter stems from delays in construction of three restaurants plaintiffs planned to open in defendant’s (sometimes, the Mall) shopping center in Massapequa, New York. Each plaintiff LLC entered into a lease with the defendant on March 30, 2012. The defendant apparently was doing business as Westfield Sunrise, the name on the cover sheet of the lease, and as noted below defendant’s affiant identifies himself as vice-president of Westfield, LLC, managing agent for the Mall.

The leases and amendments thereto contemplated a period of construction of plaintiffs’ restaurants, during which rent would not be charged. The time from which rent would begin (commencement date) would be the earlier of when each restaurant would open for business, or the fixed dates of January 15, 2014 (LIDC I), March 1, 2014 (LIDC III) and April 15, 2014 (LDIC IV). The leases all contain a force-majeure clause excusing a delay in performance based on, among things, “restrictive government laws or controls; delayed governmental or municipal action.” Financial hardship was excluded as a force-majeure event, as was the inability of contractors to meet contract dates “unless caused by such governmental acts” or “acts of Landlord.” The clause also states, however, that the occurrence of any such event shall not excuse the tenant’s obligation to pay rent “from and after the Commencement Date.” Plaintiffs hired a general contractor, PC Consulting Management Corp.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.