Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Berks County October 3, 2014, No. 13-16622 (McLaughlin v. Birdsboro Municipal Authority)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-10-2014

SPRECHER, J.,

The issue before this court is the reasonableness of defendant’s practice of charging the plaintiffs, as owners of multi-residential dwellings, a premium consumption charge. Defendant’s only resolution established that all “Water rates, rents, and charges for use of the Water System by any improved property shall be based upon and shall be computed in accordance with,” in pertinent part, the following:

1. Ready-to-Serve Charge ($15.68 for residents and $23.00 for nonresidents)

2. EDU Charge-Water ($3.50 for domestic establishments, $5,431 for commercial establishments, $8,518 for industrial establishments, and $8,518 for public establishments)

3. Consumption Charges. In addition (sic) the ready-to-serve meter charge and the minimum EDU charge, the following consumption charges are applicable to the excess consumption per meter over that allowable under the minimum charge. ($4,992 per 1000 gallons for residents, $7,371 for nonresidents)

A full review of the testimony, the record of the proceedings, and the briefs shows that the single issue raised by the plaintiffs in this litigation is the consumption charges imposed by defendant on plaintiffs’ properties. *212The stipulation of counsel of April 4, 2014 confirms this point, as does the testimony of record, including defendant’s expert, Keith Allen Hill. The issue is not the number of equivalent dwelling units (EDU) or the assignment of ready-to-serve charges. The contention is with section 3 Consumption Charges in defendant’s Resolution No._, which as stated, concerns excess consumption. Consequently, this court vacated its July 14, 2014 verdict, finding for the defendant and against the plaintiff based on Chicora Commons Limited Partnership, LLP, v. Chicora Borough Sewer Authority, 922 A.2d 986 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2007).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.