Ohio Supreme Court December 3, 2014, No. 14-AP-095 (State v. Smith)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-12-2014

O’Connor, C.J.

{¶ 1} Jessica S. McDonald, counsel for defendant in the underlying case, Coty Smith, has filed an affidavit with the clerk of this court under R.C. 2701.03 seeking to disqualify Judge Dale Crawford, a retired judge sitting by assignment, from presiding over further proceedings in case No. CRB 1401930 A-D in the Chillieothe Municipal Court.

{¶ 2} McDonald states that contrary to a court order, her client failed to appear for a recent pretrial hearing and that Judge Crawford thereafter instructed the city law director to “file the necessary criminal charges” against Smith for failure to appear. McDonald claims that in response, the law director informed the judge that the normal procedure was to issue a capias for a defendant’s failure to appear, but Judge Crawford repeated that Smith was subject to *74additional charges. McDonald concludes that by ordering the law director to file additional charges against Smith, Judge Crawford “inserted] himself into the role of the prosecution” and should therefore be removed from the underlying case.

{¶ 3} Judge Crawford has responded in writing to the affidavit, explaining that Smith had been released on a recognizance bond. The judge acknowledges that after waiting approximately 20 minutes for Smith to appear for the pretrial hearing, he “requested the prosecutor to file criminal charges” because it is a “criminal offense to knowingly fail to appear on a recognizance bond (Rev. Code 2937.29).” The judge concludes, however, that “[i]t is up to the prosecutor to follow or not to follow [his] request.”

{¶ 4} For the reasons explained below, no basis has been established to order the disqualification of Judge Crawford.

{¶ 5} It is axiomatic that judges do not possess, and should not attempt to use, prosecutorial discretion. When a judge abandons the judicial role to become an advocate for one party or another, the judge may be subject to legitimate questions about his or her impartiality.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.