United States Court of International Trade October 20, 2014, Slip Op. 14-96; Court Nos. 05-00269, 05-00582, 06-00054, 06-00348, 07-00110, 07-00294, 10-00230, 10-00245, 11-00018, 11-00250, 12-00001 (Rockwell Automation, Inc. v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-10-2014

OPINION

RIDGWAY, Judge:

In the 11 above-captioned actions, Plaintiff Rockwell Automation, Inc. contests the classification of “certain short-body timing relays (SBTRs) used in manufacturing applications” that Rockwell imported into the United States. Plaintiffs Consent Motion for Leave to File Out of Time and for Extension of Time to Remain on Reserve Calendar (“Pl.’s Out-of-Time Motion”) at 1; see also Memorandum in Support of Plaintiffs Amended Consent Motion for Leave to File Out of Time, and to Extend Time to Remain on Reserve Calendar (“Pl.’s Supp. Brief’) at 2. According to Rockwell, the Bureau of Customs and Border Protection “classified the merchandise in liquidation under HTSUS 9107.00.80 as time switches with a clock or watch movement or synchronous motor, and assessed duties accordingly.” Id. Rockwell maintains that “the merchandise is properly classified under HTSUS 8536.49.00 as electrical relays, at a lower rate of duty.” Id. Rockwell advises that, “[t]o date, twenty cases concerning this issue, including the eleven at bar, have been filed” in this court. Id. Rockwell further explains that one case, Court No. 03-00007, “was selected as a ‘test case’ and was litigated on the merits,” with summary judgment entered in Rockwell’s favor. Id.; see Rockwell Automation, Inc. v. United States, 31 CIT 692, 2007 WL 1314616 (2007); Rockwell Automation, Inc. v. United States, 31 CIT 788, 2007 WL 1498318 (2007).

Since the 2007 decision in the test case, according to Rockwell, its counsel has “worked diligently” with counsel for the Government “to attempt to dispose of all of the related cases.” Pl.’s Supp. Brief at 2. Rockwell states that “[t]he parties have been able to work out stipulated judgments on agreed statements of fact ... in seven of the cases, and continue to work toward disposition of [the 11 actions here at issue],” as well as one additional case, Court No. 13-00185, which — according to Rockwell — “is on the Reserve Calendar!

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.