District Court, D. Connecticut May 8, 2014, No. 3:08CV520 (Arrigoni Enterprises, LLC v. Town of Durham)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-05-2014

ORDER

JAMES G. CARR, Senior District Judge.

This is an action by plaintiff Arrigoni Enterprises, LLC (Arrigoni) which sought a variance from defendants the Town of Durham, Connecticut, the Durham Planing & Zoning Commission, and the Durham Zoning Board of Appeals (collectively, the defendants or Town) to excavate, crush, and remove rock for the development of three commercial buildings. The Town denied its application on the basis of a local zoning regulation.

Pending is Arrigoni’s post-trial motion seeking declaratory judgment that the zoning regulation be repealed for vagueness (Doc. 173).

For the reasons that follow, I deny Arri-goni’s motion.

Background

Arrigoni, a Connecticut company, submitted an application to the Town to develop its property. The three buildings Arri-goni wanted to erect were to be located within the Town’s Design Development *190District (DDD) zone. After receiving the application, defendants instructed plaintiff to apply for an excavation permit pursuant to § 12.05 of the Durham Zoning Regulations (the Section).

Arrigoni then prepared and submitted an excavation plan. The plan included a proposal to process 73,000 cubic yards of excavated rock by crushing it. Defendants denied the application because § 12.05 does not permit the crushing of rock in the DDD zone.

The key provision of that Section is Part 12.05.03.01.03.B which states, “No washing, crushing or other forms of processing earth products shall be conducted upon the premises unless located within a heavy industrial (HID) zone and then if must not be located within 100' of any property or street line.”1 (Doc. 68-5, at 6).

Plaintiff then sued defendants under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 claiming the Section violates the Equal Protection Clause of the U.S. Constitution and is also unconstitutionally vague. In January, 2013, the parties went to trial on plaintiffs § 1983 and equal protection claims. A jury returned a verdict for the defendants.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.