District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania May 15, 2014, Civil Action No. 13-5269 (OneBeacon America Insurance v. Urban Outfitters, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-05-2014

MEMORANDUM

DALZELL, District Judge.

The parties to this declaratory judgment action filed cross-motions for summary judgment seeking a declaration as to whether OneBeacon America Insurance Company (“OneBeacon”) and The Hanover Insurance Group (properly known as The Hanover Insurance Company and herein “Hanover”) have a duty to defend retailers Urban Outfitters, Inc. and its Anthropolo-gie, Inc. subsidiary (collectively, “Urban *429Outfitters”) in three putative class-action suits regarding the retailers’ collection of customer ZIP code data in alleged violation of state or local privacy laws.1

We will grant OneBeacon and Hanover motions for summary judgment for the reasons detailed below and deny Urban Outfitters’ motion for partial summary judgment. For the reasons that follow, we declare that neither insurer has a duty to defend either Urban Outfitters or Anthro-pologie in any of the three class actions at issue here.

I. Factual and Procedural Background

A. The Parties

This insurance dispute arises from Urban Outfitters’ request for defense coverage in three underlying lawsuits alleging that the retailers violated state statutes and common law privacy rights when they gathered personal ZIP code information while processing credit card purchases. Urban Outfitters (“UO”) MSJ at 2. Both retailers are co-defendants in Hancock v. Urban Outfitters, Inc. (“Hancock”)2 and Dremak v. Urban Outfitters, Inc. (“Dre-mak”);3 and Urban Outfitters is the sole defendant in a third action, Miller v. Urban Outfitters, Inc. (“Miller”).4 Joint Appendix (“JA”), Ex. 1-3.

OneBeacon issued Urban Outfitters a combined commercial general liability (“CGL”) and umbrella policy5 for the period July 7, 2008 to July 7, 20096 and an identical policy for July 7, 2009 to July 7, 2010,7 under which Urban Outfitters and Anthropologie are named insureds. One-Beacon MSJ at 7.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.