Court of Appeals of Georgia November 21, 2014, A14A1335; A14A1336; A14A1337; A14A1338; A14A1339; A14A1340; A14A1341; A14A1342 (First Citizens Bank & Trust, Inc. v. Ruddell)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-11-2014

Phipps, Chief Judge.

In these eight cases, First Citizens Bank & Trust, Inc. (the bank) appeals summary judgments entered against it and in favor of: E. R. Ruddell, Jr.; TWM Enterprises, LLC; Pyloros, LLC; Mary Ruddell Coulter Family, LP; Pylorus 2, LLC; First Quality Equities, Inc.; and the Estate of Mary R. Coulter (collectively, “defendants”). The summary judgments preclude the bank from recovering monies it claimed the defendants owed under various promissory notes, credit agreements, and/or guaranties.1 For the reasons explained below, the judgments in Case Nos. A14A1335, A14A1336, A14A1338, and A14A1341 are affirmed in part and reversed in part; the judgments in Case Nos. A14A1337, A14A1339, A14A1340, and A14A1342 are reversed.

In 2011, the bank filed eight separate complaints against these various defendants, pursuing in each complaint claims of breach of contract and unjust enrichment. While the cases were pending in the trial court, in April 2012, the bank conducted nonjudicial foreclosure sales of six properties that served as collateral. The bank did not thereafter seek judicial confirmation of those sales under OCGA § 44-14-161.

The defendants then filed in their respective cases motions for summary judgment, arguing that the bank’s failure to obtain confir*83mation of the six foreclosure sales barred all claims pursued in the eight complaints.2 More particularly, the defendants asserted that all debts alleged in the complaints were “inextricably intertwined” with the debts that underlay the six foreclosure sales; the defendants then characterized the bank’s claims pursued in the complaints as attempts to obtain deficiency judgments; the defendants thus argued that the bank’s quest for deficiency “judgment[s] based on loans that are inextricably intertwined to the loans secured by the Foreclosed Properties” must be denied.

The trial court conducted a hearing,3 then entered orders in June 2013 granting the motions for summary judgment.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.