Massachusetts Superior Court May 19, 2014, No. MICV201304903 (In re Pelvic Mesh/Gynecare Litigation)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-05-2014

Kottmyer, Diane M., J.

The Deponents Gregory J. Curfman, M.D., Executive Editor of the New England Journal of Medicine (the “NEJM”), and Jeffrey Drazen, M.D., its Editor-in-Chief (the “Deponents”) have moved for reconsideration of this Court’s Memorandum of Decision and Order on Motions to Quash Subpoenas dated April 12, 2014 (the “Decision”). The relevant facts are set forth in the Decision. The motion for reconsideration is denied for the following reasons.

1. The Deponents concede that the Court applied a balancing test as required under Massachusetts law. They argue that the Court failed to consider all of the relevant information and, in particular, that internal editorial deliberations including those relating to the correction of a disclosure are protected and that “disclosing communications with the authors of the article would reveal . . . the internal editorial and decision-making process of the NEJM. . . [and] this could have a deleterious effect on the NEJM.” The balance struck by the Court in the Decision is fact-specific. Critical to the ruling denying in part the motions to quash is the fact that there is substantial evidence that the Disclosure that accompanied publication of the Article was not accurate and that the Correction did not adequately correct the misstatements in the Disclosure. Facts concerning the extent to which the Disclosure and Correction were not true, the identity of the individuals who drafted the Disclosure and the Correction and the decisions made as to the wording of the Disclosure and Correction do not concern the “scientific merits” of the study described in the Article. Nothing in the record suggests that the requirement that authors disclose the extent to which a sponsor had a role in a study varies depending on the scientific merits of an article.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.