Massachusetts Superior Court April 30, 2014, SUCV200903772BLS1 (Finnegan v. Baker)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-04-2014

Billings, Thomas P., J.

For the reasons that follow, on the Appeal of Defendants/Plaintiffs-in-counterclaim from a Master’s Decision on Fee Advancement, the Initial Report of Special Master on Request for Fee Advancement is AFFIRMED.

BACKGROUND

This case concerns a protracted and hard-fought dispute between warring factions in VBenx Corporation, a Delaware business corporation. After a jury-waived trial on the plaintiffs’ claims, Judge Lauriat found for the defendants on all counts. The counterclaim, litigation of which had been stayed, was then tested by motion to dismiss, with mixed results (though most of the eleven counts survived). The counterclaim counts, and their disposition on the motion to dismiss, are as follows: _

Count Claim Against^ Disposition

1. Breach of fiduciary duty Brent Finnegan, Karen Finnegan1 Dismissed re Karen Finnegan.

2. Aiding and abetting breach of fiduciary duty Phillips, Karen Finnegan Dismissed re Karen Finnegan.

Conspiracy Brent Finnegan, Karen Finnegan, Phillips Denied.

4. Malicious prosecution Bent Finnegan, Phillips Denied.

5. Intentional interference with prospective relationship Phillips Denied.

6. Breach of fiduciary duty Phillips Denied.

7. Violation of Chapter 93A Brent Finnegan, Phillips, Back Bay Ventures Dismissed re Finnegan and Phillips.

Declaratory judgment Back Bay Ventures No motion brought.

Violation of 27V.S.A. §464 Back Bay Ventures No motion brought.

10 Declaratory judgment Brent Finnegan Denied.

11. Injunctive relief Brent Finnegan, Karen Finnegan, Phillips Denied.

In other words, most of the counterclaims against Finnegan and Phillips remain pending. The current controversy is over their claim that they are entitled to advancement of the fees and costs they have incurred, and will incur in the future, in defending the counterclaims against them. The claim is founded upon section 145 of the Delaware General *456Corporation Law and section 10 of the VBenx Bylaws.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.