Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit February 5, 2014, Nos. 11-11266, 11-11267, 11-12609 (Alabama Education Ass'n v. State Superintendent of Education)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-02-2014

lead-opinion

DUBINA, Circuit Judge:

I. BACKGROUND

This appeal came to us following the district court’s entry of a preliminary injunction preventing enforcement of Alabama Act No. 2010-761 (“the Act”), codified at Alabama Code § 17-17-5. The Act prohibits public employees from “arranging] by salary deduction or otherwise ” for payments to (1) political action committees or (2) organizations that use any portion of the dues for “political activity.” Id. § 17-17-5(b) (emphasis added). The Act then goes on to define “political activity” for the purposes of § 17-17-5(b) only, limiting it to:

a. Making contributions to or contracting with any entity which engages in any form of political communication, including communications which mention the name of a political candidate.

b. Engaging in or paying for public opinion polling.

c. Engaging in or paying for any form of political communication, including communications which mention the name of a political candidate.

d. Engaging in or paying for any type of political advertising in any medium.

e. Phone calling for any political purpose.

f. Distributing political literature of any type.

g. Providing any type of in-kind help or support to or for a political candidate.

Id. § 17 — 17—5(b)(1).

Appellees, the Alabama Education Association, its political action committee A-*1138VOTE, and a handful of its individual members, brought a pre-enforcement, facial challenge to the Act. Two days before the Act was to take effect, the district court preliminarily enjoined its enforcement on two grounds. First, the district court concluded that the “or otherwise” language suffered from a constitutional overbreadth problem and risked prohibiting protected First Amendment activity. Ala. Educ. Ass’n v. Bentley, 788 F.Supp.2d 1288, 1320 (N.D.Ala.2011) “Bentley ”.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.