United States Bankruptcy Court, M.D. Pennsylvania January 6, 2014, Bankruptcy No. 5-12-BK-02073-JJT; Adversary No. 5-13-AP-00171 (Schwab v. Ease Associates, Inc. (In re Saint Catherine Hospital of Pennsylvania, LLC))
Also known as
United States · · · 06-01-2014
OPINION
JOHN J. THOMAS, Bankruptcy Judge.
The Trustee of St. Catherine Hospital of Pennsylvania, LLC, William G. Schwab, has filed a Complaint to avoid a judgment lien under the strong arm provisions of the Bankruptcy Code found at 11 U.S.C. § 544 *813et seq. He has named as a Defendant Lease Associates, Inc., which had obtained a prepetition judgment, not against the Debtor, but against a related entity known as Saint Catherine Healthcare of Pennsylvania, LLC (Healthcare). The Trustee now moves for summary judgment setting forth facts that are generally not in dispute and that, he says, require me to enter judgment in his favor and against Lease Associates. While those facts may be somewhat convoluted, I will try to simplify them for purposes of this disposition.
On April 9, 2012, the Debtor filed for Chapter 11 which thereafter converted to Chapter 7. On November 5, 2012, the Trustee began a lawsuit in this Court against Healthcare asking for a declaratory judgment that Healthcare was an alter ego of the Debtor. Adversary No.:5:12ap-00298. Healthcare was a limited liability corporation whose managing partner was Robert Lane. Robert Lane was in Chapter 7 bankruptcy in the State of Wyoming. Lane’s Chapter 7 Trustee and Schwab, the Debtor’s Trustee, thereafter entered into an agreement which resulted in a consent judgment in Adversary No. 5:12-ap-00298 to the effect that Debtor and Healthcare conducted a “single enterprise.” This was a virtual admission that the two companies were alter egos of each other.
Schwab now argues that, by virtue of that consent judgment, Lease Associates’ judgment against Healthcare is a voidable preference by reason of the Debtor’s filing within 90 days of judgment being entered against Healthcare by Lease Associates.
The reasons why two legal entities may be treated as one, either as a single entity or consolidated estates, are many and varied.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit