Richmond County Circuit Court September 22, 2014, Case No. CL14-947 (Smith v. Simmons)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-09-2014

By Judge Melvin R. Hughes, Jr.

This case, an appeal from the General District Court, came on to be heard for trial by the Court without a jury on August 28, 2014: Plaintiff appeared pm se, and Defendant was present with counsel.

The case arises out of a dog bite incident on April 30, 2014. Plaintiff, who is Defendant’s landlord, was on the demised premises that day waiting for a prospective tenant to arrive and inspect the downstairs of the duplex residence. Defendant, Plaintiff’s tenant, lives in the apartment upstairs.

There came a time when Plaintiff went to the backyard where Defendant’s dog was present. Defendant was not present at the time. Plaintiff testified the dog attacked her with a bite on the leg which required medical attention. Her medical bills amount to about $3,700.00. She also stated that, as a result of her injury, she remained home from her employment for a total of four weeks. Plaintiff’s leg shows two large scars which appear to be permanent.

Defendant testified that he paid a $150.00 pet fee as a part of his lease. He said he had no prior knowledge of his dog’s violent behavior, and he provided a picture of a “beware of the dog” sign he posted on the entrance gate to the back yard on the side of the house. Contrary to Plaintiff’s testimony, he denied that he was restricted to having the dog in the backyard without his presence.

Plaintiff testified that the parties executed an addendum to the lease agreement which required that the dog be accompanied at all times. The Court took the case under advisement to review the Court’s electronic file and to locate the document.

The Court found an addendum between the parties in the record which states that Defendant is permitted to have a dog on the property subject to certain conditions. None of those, however, require that the dog be accompanied by its owner in the yard at all times as Plaintiff testified.

*214The record contains another item which the court was not cited to.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.