Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Monroe County July 31, 2014, No. 7997 CV 2013 (Lehigh Gas Corp. v. Stroud Township Zoning Hearing Board)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-07-2014

HARLACHER SIBUM, J.,

This matter is before the court on Lehigh Gas Corporation’s (hereinafter, “appellant”) appeal from the denial of a variance request that was made on June 7,2013. Appellant owns a travel stop located at 3577 Pennsylvania Route 611 in Bartonsville, Pennsylvania which includes a car wash, convenience store, and a fuel station. A free standing sign is located at the northernmost point of ingress/egress to and from the plaza. This sign is used to identify the services offered within the property as well as the fuel brand and pricing. In February of 2013, appellant refaced a sign on their property into a Light Emitting Diode (L.E.D.) sign. In May of 2013, a Stroud Township Zoning Officer verbally informed an employee of the appellant that the refaced sign would require a variance. Appellant filed an application to the Stroud Township Zoning Hearing Board (hereinafter, “appellee”) seeking “Relief from Sec. 9.601(c) Variance to display an electronically-activated changeable sign.” [Official record, ZHB #1,7/10/13]. Attached to the application was a type-written statement with four paragraphs which listed the reasons for seeking a variance, including convenience and safety factors. Thereafter, the board solicitor drafted a public notice that appellant filed the application and the same was recorded with the Pocono Record. In the identical documents, there was no mention of a substantive challenge to Section 9.601(c). [See official record, ZHB #2, #3, 7/10/13].

On July 10, 2013, appellee conducted a hearing in the Stroud Township Municipal Building to consider appellant’s request. The following facts were developed at the hearing: On January 20, 2003, appellant and their affiliate, Bartonsville Travel Plaza, Inc., purchased the property. This property is 5.3 acres and zoned C-2. Located within the property is an Exxon fuel station. The *268sign at issue was erected in 2003.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.