Washington Supreme Court February 12, 2015, 88317-3 (Cornelius v. Dep't of Ecology)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-02-2015

'!"· •.••~ .;

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON

SCOTT CORNELIUS, an individual, )

PALOUSE WATER CONSERVATION ) No. 88317-3

NETWORK, and SIERRA CLUB )

PALOUSE GROUP, ) En Bane

)

Appellants, )

)

v. )

)

WASHINGTON DEPARTMENT OF )

ECOLOGY, WASHINGTON STATE )

UNIVERSITY, and WASHINGTON )

POLLUTION CONTROL HEARINGS )

BOARD, )

)

Respondents. )

) Filed FEB 1 2 2015

OWENS, J. - In 2003, our legislature made substantial amendments to this

state's water law. In 2010, we found those amendments facially constitutional.

Today, Scott Cornelius, Palouse Water Conservation Network, and Sierra Club

Palouse Group (collectively Cornelius) bring an as-applied constitutional claim

(among other claims) against Washington State University (WSU), the Department of

Ecology, and the Pollution Control Hearings Board (PCHB). We find the

Cornelius v. Dep 't of Ecology

No. 88317-3

amendments were applied constitutionally and find the other claims unavailing. We

affirm.

FACTS

Cornelius and WSU both draw water from the Grande Ronde Aquifer

underlying the Palouse Basin. The aquifer is declining from overpumping. WSU has

seven groundwater rights that serve its Pullman campus with priority dates ranging

from 1934 to 1987. These rights are documented by claims, permits, or certificates

depending on when the rights were perfected. Two certificates are primarily at issue

in this case: 5070-A and 5072-A. Although the documents for some ofWSU's rights

state that their purpose was "municipal," the documents for Certificate Nos. 5070-A

and 5072-A state their purpose as "domestic." 4 Admin. Record (AR) Doc. 85, at 5

(Order on Summ. J.). The holders of"mtmicipal" water rights are now entitled to

added protections under the law. See RCW 90.14.140(2)(d). There was no added

protection for "municipal" water rights when Ecology issued Certificate Nos. 5070-A

and 5072-A.

Ecology issued Certificate No. 5070-A in 1962 and Certificate No. 5072-A in

1963.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.