Washington Supreme Court March 12, 2015, 88819-1 (Fergen v. Sestero)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-03-2015

'Th!& opinion was filed for record

at ,8:s:>o em on (\1'\:;;tM (:2-,?Q l-6

~

A.Onard R. Carpenter

~~P#~ne Qeurt Clerk

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON

DANI FERGEN, individually and as )

personal representative of the )

ESTATE OF PAUL J. FERGEN, )

and minors, BRAYDEN FERGEN )

and SYDNEY FERGEN, ) No. 88819-1

individually, ) (consolidated with

) No. 89192-3)

Petitioners, )

)

v. )

)

JOHN D. SESTERO, M.D., )

individually, and as an employee/ ) En Bane

shareholder/agent of Defendant )

Spokane Internal Medicine and )

SPOKANE INTERNAL MEDICINE,)

P.S., a Washington corporation, )

)

Respondents. ) Filed MAR 1 2 2015

______________________ )

)

ANIL APPUKUTTAN, )

)

Appellant, )

v. )

)

OVERLAKE MEDICAL CENTER, )

PUGET SOUND PHYSICIANS, )

PLLC, ALAN B. BROWN, M.D., )

MARCUS TRIONE, M.D., and )

TINA NEIDERS, M.D., )

)

Respondents. )

-------------- )

Fergen v. Sestero, No. 88819-1

FAIRHURST, J.-"The most critical element of most medical malpractice

claims based on negligence ... is the standard of care owed by the doctor to his or

her patient." Watson v. Hockett, 107 Wn.2d 158, 162, 727 P.2d 669 (1986). In order

to provide a lay jury with the best possible understanding of this fundamental, yet

often confusing, component of legal liability, supplemental standard of care

instructions are sometimes used in addition to the basic instructions. One of these

supplemental instructions is the exercise of judgment instruction, which reminds

juries that if a physician exercises the reasonable care and skill generally required

by his or her position, just choosing between alternate treatments or diagnoses does

not make them legally liable for making a wrong choice.

This is a consolidated case of two medical malpractice suits. In each case, an

exercise of judgment jury instruction similar to 6 Washington Practice: Washington

Pattern Jury Instructions: Civi/105.08 (6th ed. 2012) (WPI) was given. 1 Both juries

found in favor of the defendants and both plaintiffs assign error.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.