Superior Court of Pennsylvania April 24, 2015, 505 MDA 2014 (Geisinger Clinic v. Radziewicz, M.)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-04-2015

J-A31012-14

2015 PA Super 95

GEISINGER CLINIC IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF

PENNSYLVANIA

Appellant

v.

MARK M. RADZIEWICZ, D.O.

Appellee No. 505 MDA 2014

Appeal from the Order Entered February 24, 2014

In the Court of Common Pleas of Montour County

Civil Division at No(s): 449-2013

BEFORE: BOWES, J., OTT, J., and STABILE, J.

DISSENTING OPINION BY OTT, J.: FILED APRIL 24, 2015

Because I believe that the certified record demonstrates the trial court

based its decision on actual, not merely apparently, reasonable grounds, I

would affirm the denial of the preliminary and permanent injunction that

Geisinger Clinic sought against Mark M. Radziewicz, D.O. Accordingly, I

respectfully dissent.

Our scope of review “on an appeal from a decree either granting or

denying a preliminary injunction is to examine the record only to determine

if there were any apparently reasonable grounds for the action of the court

below.” Bryant v. Sling Testing, 369 A.2d 1164, 1167 (Pa. 1977) quoting

Lindenfelser v. Lindenfelser, 123 A.2d 626 (Pa. 1956) (emphasis added).

Further,

Our law permits equitable enforcement of employee covenants

not to compete only so far as reasonably necessary for the

protection of the employer. Bettinger v. Carl Berke

J-A31012-14

Associates, Inc., 455 Pa. 100, 314 A.2d 296 (1974); Reading

Aviation Service Co. v. Berolet, 454 Pa. 488, 311 A.2d 628

(1973). However, where the covenant imposes restrictions

broader than necessary to protect the employer, we have

repeatedly held that a court of equity may grant enforcement

limited to those portions of the restrictions which are reasonably

necessary for the protection of the employer, Jacobson & Co.

v. International Environment Corp., 427 Pa. 439, 235 A.2d

612 (1967) (unanimous).

Sidco Paper Company v. Aaron, 351 A.2d 250 (Pa. 1976) (further citation

omitted)1.

There are six elements that must be established in order to obtain a

preliminary injunction.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.