Supreme Court of Georgia May 11, 2015, S15A0362, S15A0641 (McHugh Fuller Law Group, Pllc v. Pruitthealth-Toccoa, LLC)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-05-2015

In the Supreme Court of Georgia

Decided: May 11, 2015

S15A0362. McHUGH FULLER LAW GROUP, PLLC v.

PRUITTHEALTH-TOCCOA, LLC.

S15A0641. McHUGH FULLER LAW GROUP, PLLC v.

PRUITTHEALTH-TOCCOA, LLC.

HUNSTEIN, Justice.

In these appeals, Appellant McHugh Fuller Law Group, PLLC (“McHugh

Fuller”) challenges both the award of a permanent injunction to Appellee

PruittHealth-Toccoa, LLC (“PruittHealth”) and a subsequent trial court order

excluding certain filings from the appellate record in the original appeal. We

conclude that the trial court did err, both in granting a permanent injunction

following only an interlocutory hearing and in its exclusion of filings from the

appellate record. Accordingly, we vacate the award of the permanent injunction,

reverse the order designating the appellate record, and remand for further

proceedings.

On April 17, 2014, McHugh Fuller, a Mississippi-based law firm, ran a

full-page advertisement in a Northeast Georgia local newspaper, The Toccoa

Record, noting that Heritage Healthcare of Toccoa, a Stephens County nursing

home owned by PruittHealth, had been cited by the government for deficiencies

in the care of its residents and inviting those suspecting abuse or neglect of a

loved one at the facility to call the law firm. On the following day, PruittHealth

filed a verified complaint for temporary and permanent injunctive relief under

the Georgia Uniform Deceptive Trade Practices Act (UDTPA), OCGA § 10-1-

373 (a)1, and petitioned ex parte for a temporary restraining order. That same

day, the Stephens County Superior Court entered a temporary restraining order

enjoining McHugh Fuller from publishing, in any newspaper or other media,

advertisements regarding PruittHealth utilizing the language of the April 17 ad.

The order also scheduled a hearing a few weeks thereafter to “determine

whether injunctive relief should continue.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.