Supreme Court of Pennsylvania July 20, 2015, 126 MAP 2014 (In re: Ballot Quest to Concord TwpAppeal of Brown)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-07-2015

[J-110-2014][M.O. ̶ Stevens, J.]

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA

MIDDLE DISTRICT

IN RE: PETITION TO SUBMIT BALLOT : No. 126 MAP 2014

QUESTION TO CONCORD TOWNSHIP :

VOTERS : Appeal from the Order of Commonwealth

: Court at No. 1426 CD 2014 dated

DELAWARE COUNTY BOARD : September 26, 2014 Affirming the order of

OF ELECTIONS, : the Delaware County Court of Common

: Pleas, Civil Division, at No. 2014-06512

Intervenor : dated August 14, 2014.

:

:

APPEAL OF: COLETTE BROWN : SUBMITTED: November 21, 2014

DISSENTING OPINION

MR. CHIEF JUSTICE SAYLOR DECIDED: July 20, 2015

The majority concludes that Section 207 of the First Class Township Code,1 53

P.S. §55207, unambiguously permitted the filing of Appellant’s petition, notwithstanding

that such petition was submitted well after the occurrence of the first election at least

ninety days after the ascertainment by United States census that Concord Township

exceded the population threshold for conversion to a first-class township. According to

the majority, the Commonwealth Court’s contrary interpretation of the statute alters its

plain language. See Majority Opinion, slip op. at 13. The majority also asserts that the

statutory allowance for resubmission after an unsuccessful referendum “contradicts the

opposing parties’ claim that such questions may only be submitted immediately after the

census or special enrollment.” Id. at 14. In terms of policy, the majority relies upon

“actual census data” reflecting strong population gains in the relevant geographic area,

1

Act of June 24, 1931, P.L. 1206 (as amended, 53 P.S. §§55101-58502).

albeit post-dating the enactment of both the relevant statute and the salient

amendments, as dispelling Appellees’ position that Section 207 was designed to ensure

a reasonably close temporal relationship between population ascertainments and a

referendum concerning second-to-first-class-township conversion. Id. at 15.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.