Court of Appeals of Maryland July 24, 2015, 82/14 (Scarfield v. Muntjan)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-07-2015

Frank D. Scarfield, Sr., et al. v. Peter A. Muntjan, et al., No. 82, September Term, 2014,

Opinion by Adkins, J.

CIVIL PROCEDURE — JURY DEMAND — MARYLAND RULE 2-325 —

WAIVER — REVIVAL: When an amended complaint with an accompanying jury

demand contains only one new count, which is dismissed for failure to state a claim, that

new issue and timely jury demand are insufficient to revive a previously waived jury

demand for counts in the original complaint.

Circuit Court for Baltimore City

Case No.: 24-C-10-009292

Argued: May 6, 2015

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS

OF MARYLAND

No. 82

September Term, 2014

FRANK D. SCARFIELD, SR., et al.

v.

PETER A. MUNTJAN, et al.

Barbera, C.J.

*Harrell

Battaglia

Greene

Adkins

McDonald

Watts,

JJ.

Opinion by Adkins, J.

Filed: July 24, 2015

* Harrell, J., now retired, participated in the

hearing and conference of this case while an

active member of this Court; after being recalled

pursuant to the Constitution, Article IV, Section

3A, he also participated in the decision and

adoption of this opinion.

The right to a trial by jury in civil proceedings is enshrined in the Maryland

Declaration of Rights1 and further guaranteed in Maryland Rule 2-5112. But the

Legislature and Courts may impose reasonable limitations on that right. One such

limitation is found in Maryland Rule 2-325, which provides that a party’s failure to demand

a jury trial within 15 days after service of the last pleading directed to the issue constitutes

a waiver by that party of a jury trial. An exception to this waiver rule applies when a party

files an amended complaint, asserting a new substantive issue and demanding a jury trial.

Under such a circumstance, the new claim may revive a previously waived jury trial. In

this case, we must determine whether an amended complaint in which a party demanded a

jury trial but added only one new count, which was dismissed for failure to state a claim,

revives a previously waived jury trial.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.