Court of Appeals of Washington July 27, 2015, 71519-4 (State Of Washington v. Doreen Yvette Starrish)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-07-2015

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE STATE OF WASHINGTON

STATE OF WASHINGTON,

No. 71519-4-1 fe

Respondent,

DIVISION ONE -^

v.

DOREEN STARRISH, UNPUBLISHED OPINION \

PO

Appellant. FILED: July 27. 2015

Spearman, C.J. — Doreen Starrish was convicted of second degree felony

murder and possession of heroin when witnesses saw her stab her former

significant other during a heated argument. Starrish moved for a mistrial, arguing

that a police detective gave improper opinion testimony about witness

truthfulness (1) in general and (2) with regard to a particular witness. The motion

was denied and Starrish appeals, claiming she was denied her right to a fair trial.

Starrish also objected to "to convict" instructions as violating her Sixth

Amendment right to a jury trial. We find no error and affirm.

FACTS

Doreen Starrish and Aaron Smith met in 2000 as teenagers and had a

volatile relationship. The couple had two daughters and continued to live together

through 2012, even though they had ceased being romantically involved. In May

of that year, Starrish was dating Jonathon Jones. Another couple was also

staying in the house, Dianne Berniard and Reginald Tramble.

No. 71519-4-1/2

On May 3, 2012, Smith was preparing breakfast and getting their

daughters ready for school. Berniard and Tramble were sleeping on the sofa in

the living room. Starrish had come back to the house with Jones and they went

into her bedroom. Smith became upset, opened the door, called Starrish a name,

and closed the door again. Smith opened the door again and yelled at Starrish,

making her angry. Starrish came out about fifteen minutes later and claimed that

Smith took her stuff. Starrish then grabbed a knife and advanced on Smith. Smith

took the knife away and threw it aside. Starrish grabbed a second knife and

stabbed Smith in the chest. Starrish and Jones left, while Smith collapsed and

Tramble and Berniard called the police.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.