Court of Appeals of Washington August 17, 2015, 72263-8-I (State Of Washington v. Sayiden H. Mohamed)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-08-2015

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON

STATE OF WASHINGTON, )

) No. 72263-8-1 t-O

yio

-<r

Appellant, ) CI y>zv

) DIVISION ONE JB.

cz u-•

en C..) —<,

v. ) •—

~r\

~^v-.

) PUBLISHED OPINION ^a Sr-O'

SAYIDEN HUSSEIN MOHAMED, ) 33»

COPY-

ZS. =;Tr-

)

CO

Respondent. ) FILED: August 17, 2015 *•

CH'-"

—'.O

XT o-~

cn :£•*-

Trickey, J. — A jury convicted Sayiden Mohamed of two counts of third degree

assault. Mohamed thereafter moved for a new trial based on the admission of his prior

convictions under Evidence Rule (ER) 806. The trial court granted the motion, concluding

that the admission was contrary to a Court of Appeals, Division Two decision, State v.

Lucas, 167Wn. App. 100, 271 P.3d 394 (2012). The State appeals the trial court's ruling.

The defense expert witness testified about Mohamed's out-of-court statements.

The State contends that Mohamed's statements were offered to prove the truth of the

matter asserted, thereby triggering the application of ER 806. But as in Lucas, wherewe

held that out-of-court statements on which experts base their opinions are not hearsay,

the statements here were not substantive evidence but rather offered for the limited

purpose of explaining the basis of the expert's opinion. Thus, consistent with the holding

in Lucas, we affirm.

FACTS

On April 4, 2014, Everett Police Officers Jeff Klages and Michael Keith were

dispatched to Mohamed's residence to respond to several 911 hang-up telephone calls

originating from the residence. The officers made contact with Mohamed and spoke with

him for about 10 to 15 minutes. Mohamed appeared to be drinking alcohol that evening;

No. 72263-8-1 / 2

the officers noted an odor of alcohol on his breath and person. The officers released

Mohamed when they were finished speaking with him. Mohamed returned inside his

residence.

Shortly thereafter, the officers learned that Mohamed had an outstanding warrant

for his arrest.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.