Court of Appeals of Washington August 31, 2015, 72612-9-I (Swedish Health Services, App. v. Dept. Of Health Of The State Of Wa., Res.)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-08-2015

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON

SWEDISH HEALTH SERVICES, a No. 72612-9-

Washington nonprofit corporation,

DIVISION ONE

Appellant, C-

v.

o

DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH OF THE PUBLISHED

en

STATE OF WASHINGTON,

FILED: August 31. 2015

Respondent.

Cox, J. — The Department of Health grants certificates of need to

hospitals within identified planning areas based on regulatory criteria. Here, one

of two primary criteria is that "[a]ll existing [percutaneous coronary interventions]

programs in that planning area are meeting or exceeding the minimum volume

standard."1 It is undisputed that two such programs in the identified planning

area where Swedish Health Services seeks a certificate of need are not meeting

this "minimum volume standard." Because controlling regulations bar issuing a

certificate of need under these circumstances, the Department properly denied

Swedish's request for a certificate of need. We affirm.

1WAC 246-310-720.

No. 72612-9-1/2

The material facts are undisputed. Swedish operates two independently

licensed hospitals in Seattle—First Hill and Cherry Hill—located approximately

eight blocks from each other. Currently, Swedish's cardiology program is

consolidated in its Cherry Hill location. When First Hill patients require cardiac

care, Swedish transfers them to Cherry Hill.

Swedish decided to reestablish a cardiology program at First Hill.

Accordingly, Swedish applied for a certificate of need from the Department to

perform elective percutaneous coronary interventions (PCIs) at First Hill. PCIs

are "invasive but nonsurgical mechanical procedures and devices that are used

by cardiologists for the revascularization of obstructed coronary arteries."2 These

procedures can be elective or non-elective, but a hospital must obtain a

certificate of need to provide elective PCIs.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.