Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit April 28, 2015, 14-5597 (Cincinnati Insurance Company v. Larry Banks)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-04-2015

NOT RECOMMENDED FOR PUBLICATION

File Name: 15a0308n.06

No. 14-5597

UNITED STATES COURTS OF APPEALS FILED

FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT Apr 28, 2015

DEBORAH S. HUNT, Clerk

CINCINNATI INSURANCE CO., )

)

Plaintiff-Appellant, )

)

v. ) ON APPEAL FROM THE

) UNITED STATES DISTRICT

LARRY BANKS, et ux., ) COURT FOR THE EASTERN

) DISTRICT OF TENNESSEE

Defendants-Appellees. )

)

)

BEFORE: BATCHELDER, MOORE, and SUTTON, Circuit Judges.

ALICE M. BATCHELDER, Circuit Judge. In this diversity case, Cincinnati Insurance

Company (“CIC”) appeals a verdict rendered against it in favor of Larry and Wanda Sue Banks

(collectively “Banks”), whose home was damaged by fire in 2011, and the district court’s

denying CIC a new trial. Banks insured the home through CIC, and although CIC cited several

reasons for not covering the damage, pursuant to Tennessee law CIC paid the mortgage balance

to the bank that held the mortgage on the property. CIC then filed suit against Banks to recover

that payment, and Banks filed a counterclaim seeking payment for the value of the property in

excess of the outstanding mortgage, as well as personal property. After discovery and an eight-

day trial, a jury rendered a verdict in favor of Banks. CIC raises fifteen issues on appeal

covering manifold aspects of this litigation. We AFFIRM.

No. 14-5597

Cincinnati Ins. Co. v. Larry Banks, et ux.

I. FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY

Plaintiff Cincinnati Insurance Company (“CIC”) is an Ohio insurance company, and

Defendants Larry Banks and Wanda Sue Banks (“Banks”) are citizens of Tennessee. CIC

insured Banks’ residential property in Manchester, Tennessee. The policy covers the dwelling,

other structures, personal property, and any loss of use. The parties dispute whether this is an

“all-risk policy,” covering all direct physical loss unless otherwise excluded. On November 28,

2011, the property was damaged by fire. On March 14, 2012, Banks filed a claim for

$1,904,309.64. On March 17, 2012, CIC denied the claim.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.