Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas September 23, 2015, PD-1595-14 (Liverman v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-09-2015

IN THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS

OF TEXAS

NO. PD-1595-14, PD-1596-14

ROGER LIVERMAN AND AARON LIVERMAN, Appellants

v.

THE STATE OF TEXAS

ON STATE’S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW

FROM THE SECOND COURT OF APPEALS

DENTON COUNTY

K ELLER, P.J., delivered the opinion of the Court in which K EASLER,

H ERVEY, A LCALA, R ICHARDSON, Y EARY and N EWELL, JJ., joined. J OHNSON, J.,

concurred. M EYERS, J., dissented.

We must determine whether a person commits the crime of securing the execution of

documents by deception when he files a false mechanic’s lien affidavit with the county clerk. We

conclude that such a person does not commit that crime because he does not cause “another” to

“execute” a document affecting property or pecuniary interests.

I. BACKGROUND

A. Facts and Trial

Appellants filed mechanic’s lien affidavits in the Denton County Clerk’s Office. These

LIVERMAN — 2

affidavits alleged that appellants had performed “labor and/or materials” worth a certain amount of

money1 on the home of Katheryn Payne. As a result of these filings, the State charged appellants

with securing the execution of documents by deception. The indictments alleged that appellants

caused Cynthia Mitchell, the county clerk, to sign or execute the mechanic’s lien affidavits.

Appellants were convicted, fined, and placed on community supervision.2

B. Appeal

The court of appeals reversed appellants’ convictions and rendered judgments of acquittal.3

The court held that the evidence was legally insufficient to support the convictions because “the

conduct of the court clerk filing and recording” the mechanic’s lien affidavit in each case “was not

the signing or executing of a document as contemplated by subsection 32.46(a)(1).”4 In arriving at

this conclusion, the court of appeals held that it need look no further than the two subsections of

Penal Code § 32.46.5 The court observed that subsection (a)(1) uses the verbs “sign and execute”

while subsection (a)(2) uses the verbs “file and record.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.