California Supreme Court October 15, 2015, S055856M (People v. Romero and Self)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-10-2015

Filed 10/14/15 (unmodified opn. attached)

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF CALIFORNIA

THE PEOPLE, )

)

Plaintiff and Respondent, )

) S055856

v. )

)

ORLANDO GENE ROMERO and )

CHRISTOPHER SELF, )

) Riverside County

Defendants and Appellants. ) Super. Ct. No. CR46579

___________________________________)

MODIFICATION OF OPINION

THE COURT:

The opinion herein, published at 62 Cal.4th 1, is modified as follows:

1. In 62 Cal.4th at page 42, at the end of part II.B.4.b., a new paragraph is added,

reading as follows:

To the extent Romero also claims that CALJIC No. 3.02 improperly allowed the

jury to find that he aided and abetted certain nontarget offenses other than the murders —

i.e., attempted murder, aggravated mayhem, and shooting at an occupied vehicle — based

on the doctrine of natural and probable consequences, we reject the claim. It appears in

his view the instruction erroneously relieved the jury of the duty to determine whether he

actually had the intent to encourage or facilitate these nontarget offenses. He is mistaken.

Aider and abettor liability under the natural and probable consequences doctrine does not

require assistance with or actual knowledge and intent relating to the nontarget offense . .

. . (People v. Chiu, supra, 59 Cal.4th at p. 165.) ‘Because the nontarget offense is

unintended, the mens rea of the aider and abettor with respect to that offense is irrelevant

and culpability is imposed simply because a reasonable person could have foreseen the

commission of the nontarget crime.’ (Id. at p. 164.)

2. In 62 Cal.4th at page 58, the final sentence of part II.C.6 is deleted.

1

Substitute this new sentence reading: We further conclude this error and any assumed

error are not prejudicial when considered cumulatively, nor have defendants otherwise

demonstrated that they were denied a fair trial.

This modification does not change the judgment.

The petitions for rehearing are denied.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.