Supreme Court of Georgia June 29, 2015, S15A0032 (Whatley v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-06-2015

297 Ga. 399

FINAL COPY

S15A0032. WHATLEY v. THE STATE.

MELTON, Justice.

On March 28, 2013, Bernadette Bowie Whatley was indicted for

withholding information from a practitioner pursuant to OCGA § 16-13-43 (a)

(6). That statute deals with the distribution of controlled substances by

prescription and provides that it is unlawful to "withhold information from a

practitioner that such person has obtained a controlled substance of a similar

therapeutic use in a concurrent time period from another practitioner." On April

24, 2013, Whatley filed a general demurrer, contending among other things that

the statute was unconstitutionally vague. The trial court ruled that OCGA §

16-13-43 (a) (6) was not unconstitutionally vague on its face, and we granted

Whatley’s application for an interlocutory appeal to consider the propriety of

this ruling. As set forth below, we affirm the denial of Whatley’s general

demurrer under the right-for-any-reason doctrine.

It is well settled that the

void for vagueness doctrine of the due process clause requires that

a challenged statute or ordinance give a person of ordinary

intelligence fair warning that specific conduct is forbidden or

mandated and provide sufficient specificity so as not to encourage

arbitrary and discriminatory enforcement. Vagueness challenges .

. . that do not implicate First Amendment freedoms must be

examined in the light of the facts of the case to be decided.

(Emphasis supplied.) Parker v. City of Glennville, 288 Ga. 34, 35 (1) (701 SE2d

182) (2010). “[A] person ‘who engages in some conduct that is clearly

proscribed cannot complain of the vagueness of the law as applied to the

conduct of others.’ [Cits.]” Izzo v. State, 257 Ga. 109, 110 (1) (356 SE2d 204)

(1987). “ ‘A court should therefore examine the complainant's conduct before

analyzing other hypothetical applications of the law.’ [Cits.]” Catoosa County

v. R.N. Talley Properties, 282 Ga. 373, 375 (651 SE2d 7) (2007).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.