Supreme Court of Georgia May 11, 2015, S14G1223 (Bostick v. Cmm Properties, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-05-2015

297 Ga. 55

FINAL COPY

S14G1223. BOSTICK v. CMM PROPERTIES, INC. et al.

HINES, Presiding Justice.

This Court granted certiorari to the Court of Appeals in Bostick v. CMM

Properties, 327 Ga. App. 137 (755 SE2d 895) (2014), to consider whether the

Court of Appeals erred when it found an identity of parties (or their privies)

sufficient to permit the application of res judicata. See OCGA § 9-12-40.1 For

the reasons that follow, we find that the Court of Appeals erred in this regard,

and consequently, we reverse and remand.

The facts as found by the Court of Appeals are the following. In January

1992, Diversified Capital Management, Inc. (“Diversified”) leased premises

designated as a grocery store to James Bostick (“Bostick”). In August 1992,

Diversified assigned its rights as lessor to Ingram Timber Enterprises, L.P.

1

OCGA § 9-12-40 provides:

A judgment of a court of competent jurisdiction shall be conclusive

between the same parties and their privies as to all matters put in issue or

which under the rules of law might have been put in issue in the cause

wherein the judgment was rendered until the judgment is reversed or set

aside.

(“Ingram”). In October 2000, Bostick, with the approval of Ingram, subleased

the property to CMM Properties, Inc. (“CMM”). The sublease was subject to all

the terms of the original lease, referred to by the parties as the “master lease.”

In June 2005, Ingram filed suit in superior court against CMM and three

individual guarantors of the sublease (collectively “the CMM parties”), but not

against Bostick. Ingram claimed default under the terms of the master lease and

sublease, and sought liquidated damages under paragraph 22 of the master lease.

The trial court granted summary judgment to the CMM parties, finding that the

purported liquidated damages sought under paragraph 22 constituted a void and

unenforceable penalty. Ingram never appealed that final judgment.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.