Supreme Court of Pennsylvania October 27, 2015, 49 EAP 2013 (Commonwealth, Aplt. v. Archie, B.)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-10-2015

[J-67A-C-2014][M.O. – Eakin, J.]

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA

EASTERN DISTRICT

COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA, : No. 47 EAP 2013

:

Appellant : Appeal from the Judgment of the

: Superior Court entered on 5/15/12 at

v. : No. 1268 EDA 2011, reargument denied

: 7/18/12, vacating and remanding the

KATRINA MOODY, : judgment of sentence entered on

: 5/6/11, in the Philadelphia Municipal

Appellee : Court, Criminal Division at No. MC-51-

: MD-0000083-2011

:

COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA, : No. 48 EAP 2013

:

Appellant : Appeal from the Judgment of the

: Superior Court entered on 5/15/12 at

v. : No. 1310 EDA 2011, reargument denied

: 7/18/12, vacating and remanding the

BARBARA IVERY, : judgment of sentence entered on

: 5/6/11, in the Philadelphia Municipal

Appellee : Court, Criminal Division at No. MC-51-

: MD-0000085-2011

:

COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA, : No. 49 EAP 2013

:

Appellant : Appeal from the Judgment of the

: Superior Court entered on 5/15/12 at

v. : No. 1316 EDA 2011, reargument denied

: 7/18/12, vacating and remanding the

BERNADETTE ARCHIE, : judgment of sentence entered on

: 5/6/11, in the Philadelphia Municipal

Appellee : Court, Criminal Division at No. MC-51-

: MD-0000084-2011

:

: ARGUED: September 9, 2014

DISSENTING OPINION

MR. CHIEF JUSTICE SAYLOR DECIDED: October 27, 2015

In my view, there are simply too many irregularities associated with the

summarily-imposed direct criminal contempt convictions in this case for them to be

sustained. For example, at the initial summary hearing, the common pleas court

foreclosed the presentation of anything, in the form of either statements or evidence,

from Appellees based on its own concern for Appellees’ Fifth Amendment rights. See

N.T., Apr. 6, 2011, at 13 (“[R]ather than have you say anything at this point, I think I’m

going to appoint each of you attorneys.”). Having then explained that “before I make a

final finding, I want you to have attorneys to be able to talk to you so you can present

your case,” id.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.