Texas Court of Appeals, 14th District (Houston) September 29, 2015, 14-14-00515-CV (in the Estate of Adel Sheshtawy)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-09-2015

Affirmed and Majority and Dissenting Opinions filed September 29, 2015.

In The

Fourteenth Court of Appeals

NO. 14-14-00515-CV

IN THE ESTATE OF ADEL SHESHTAWY, DECEASED

On Appeal from the Probate Court No. 1

Harris County, Texas

Trial Court Cause No. 407,499-406

DISSENTING OPINION

I disagree with the majority’s conclusion that because Valentina signed a

settlement agreement waiving her homestead rights, she is unable to contest the

validity of that very agreement. I therefore respectfully dissent.

Rule 91a provides a mechanism for the quick dismissal of causes of action

with no basis in law or fact, as judged solely by the sufficiency of the pleadings

raising the cause of action and any properly attached pleading exhibits. Tex. R.

Civ. P. 91a.1, 91a.6. It is a harsh remedy that should be strictly construed. See

Gaskill v. VHS San Antonio Partners, LLC, 456 S.W.3d 234, 238 (Tex. App.—San

Antonio 2014, pet. filed). A cause of action has no basis in law—the part of the

rule on which the majority appears to rely—if the allegations, taken as true,

together with inferences reasonably drawn from them, do not entitle the claimant to

the relief sought. See Tex. R. Civ. P. 91a.

The majority essentially holds that because Valentina admitted in her

petition that she signed a settlement agreement that included an apparent waiver of

her homestead rights, she has no possible avenue for asserting those homestead

rights to prevent the sale of her home. While acknowledging that in her petition

Valentina asserts the settlement agreement at issue was “grossly unfair,” the

majority emphasizes that she does not explicitly seek revocation of the agreement

on that basis. Valentina, however, does seek to enjoin performance under the

terms of the agreement. The clear implication of this request is that the waiver of

homestead rights contained in the settlement agreement should not be enforced

because it would be unconscionable to do so.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.