Texas Supreme Court November 2, 2015, WR-76,991-09 (Nyabwa, Collins Omandi)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-11-2015

,]w-|Qq [~_()OJI. ¢O,IL

TEXAS COURT OF CR||VIINAL APPEALS`

WR-76, 991-09 _

WR-76, 991-10

WR-76, 991-11

BR|EF IN SUPPORT OF ACTUAL INNOCENCE

REcElvEDlN ;

c"ouRToFcR¢MlNALAPPEALs ` `

NUV 02 2015

Abemcosta,clerk ' ¥_ '

Collins O._ Nyabwa

Petitionér(Pro se) _

1341 w.43'dstreet,#163 _- _,

Houston, Tx 77018 .~ 4 * l_ ~;.-'1:-_

ACTUAL lNNOCENCE

On 10/18/2015 this court granted habeas relief in Ex Parte Curt/'s Fournier (WR-82, 102-01) and

Ex Parte Christopher Dowden (WR-82, 103-01), defendants who had previously been convicted

under the now defunct Online Solicitation of a i\/iinor Statutel. This court however denied thel d

defendants' Actual innocence claims_. v

On 3/9/2015 petitioner filed an Articie 11.07 Post Conviction Habeas Corpus (WR-76,

991-09, 10 and 11) making a similar Actual innocence claim. At the time of filing (3/9/2015) the '

Texas Court of Crimina| Appeals had not spoken definitively on how the state should handle '

Actual innocence claims by criminal defendants convicted based on unconstitutional statutes.

Without any Texas precedent, petitioner’s arguments for Actual innocence relied solely on ~

federal iaw. Now that the court has set a Texas standard for Actual innocence, petitioner is: - '- - ' " "

forced to make his Texas State claim. For the following reasons, petitioner will demonstrate n

that even under the new standard, he is still entitled to Actual innocence,

1. LEGALLY BARRED To PRosEcuTE

lt is easy to lump all criminal convictions based on unconstitutional statutes together. However' : n

as this court is fully aware, every criminal conviction comes with its own unique set of

circumstances. Even though petitioner’s Actual innocence claim appears strikingly similar to L:'_)g'

Parte Fournier and Ex Parte Dowden, there is a night-and-day difference between them.

Texas law provides a mechanism for criminal defendants to terminate their criminal

prosecution if their statute of conviction is unconstitutiona|.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.